GameStop Pro Card Price Hike: Lock In TCG Deals Before Sunday
Leaked GameStop guidance points to higher Pokémon product prices and fewer Pro perks starting Sunday. Here’s how collectors can use CardGrade to act before the window closes.
Loading...
Loading...
Leaked GameStop guidance points to higher Pokémon product prices and fewer Pro perks starting Sunday. Here’s how collectors can use CardGrade to act before the window closes.
In short: In early 2025 GameStop began pricing Pokemon TCG products 11–33% above MSRP at launch, eroding the value of Pro membership discounts for TCG buyers. This was the 2025 situation. When acquisition costs rise, every grading decision matters more — pre-screen your best pulls before committing to PSA fees.
GameStop has been quietly making life more expensive for trading card collectors throughout 2025. The company is now routinely listing Pokemon TCG products above MSRP at release, a practice that would have been unthinkable from a major retailer two years ago.
The Prismatic Evolutions Super-Premium Collection has an MSRP of $89.99. GameStop listed it at $99.99. Marnie and Steven Rival Battle Decks carry an MSRP of $14.99 each. GameStop charges $17.99. Slashing Legends Tins retail for $26.99 at MSRP. GameStop lists them at $29.99.
For the Destined Rivals set, GameStop's prices landed 20% to 33% above MSRP across most products. This isn't a pricing error. It's a strategy.
If you're a GameStop Pro member buying TCG products, your cost structure just changed. Here's what that means and how to adapt.
Until early 2025, GameStop priced Pokemon TCG products at or near MSRP. Sometimes products went on sale. Pro members received a 5% discount on top of retail pricing. The math was straightforward, and GameStop was a reliable source for picking up booster boxes, ETBs, and special collections at fair prices.
That's no longer the case. PokeBeach first reported that GameStop began listing Pokemon TCG products above MSRP upon release in February 2025. This wasn't limited to a single product or a temporary pricing glitch. It became the pattern for subsequent releases throughout the year.
The above-MSRP pricing applies to in-store and online purchases. Even with a Pro membership's 5% discount, collectors are paying more than MSRP for products they could find at retail price (or below) from other sellers.
Pricing examples from 2025:
| Product | MSRP | GameStop Price | Markup |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prismatic Evolutions Super-Premium Collection | $89.99 | $99.99 | +11% |
| Rival Battle Decks (each) | $14.99 | $17.99 | +20% |
| Slashing Legends Tins | $26.99 | $29.99 | +11% |
| Destined Rivals products (avg.) | Varies | +20-33% | 20-33% |
GameStop Pro membership costs $25 per year. The membership includes a $5 monthly coupon ($60/year in potential savings), a 5% discount on purchases, and other perks like early access and points accumulation.
For TCG collectors, the 5% discount was the primary draw. On a $150 booster box, that's $7.50 saved. Buy two boxes a month, and the membership pays for itself in under two months.
But the 5% discount doesn't help when GameStop's base price is 20% above MSRP. A $26.99 tin listed at $29.99 with a 5% Pro discount costs $28.49, still $1.50 above MSRP. The discount creates an illusion of savings while you're still overpaying relative to other retailers.
The annual $60 in $5 monthly coupons remains valuable, but only if you're buying items at or below competitive pricing. If you use a $5 coupon on a product that's $10 over MSRP, you've saved $5 but overpaid $5 net.
Should you renew GameStop Pro?
If you buy games, accessories, and non-TCG products from GameStop regularly, the membership still has value through the 5% discount on normally-priced items and the monthly coupons.
If you're renewing primarily for TCG purchases, run the numbers against what you'd pay buying the same products from Walmart, Target, Pokemon Center, or local card shops. In many cases, the TCG savings no longer justify the $25 annual fee on their own.
GameStop's markup creates an opportunity to compare alternatives:
Pokemon Center (pokemoncenter.com) The official Pokemon Company storefront sells at MSRP. Availability is the main challenge; popular products sell out quickly and restocks are unpredictable. No membership fee. Free shipping on orders over $20.
Walmart and Target Both retailers consistently price Pokemon TCG products at MSRP. In-store availability varies by location, but online inventory has improved. Neither charges above MSRP, and both frequently run sales or clearance pricing on older products.
Local Card Shops (LCS) Independent card shops often price at or slightly above MSRP for new releases, but many offer loyalty programs, pre-order discounts, or bundle deals. Supporting local shops also builds relationships that can lead to early access, trade-in opportunities, and local community connections.
Online TCG Retailers Sites like TCGPlayer, Troll and Toad, and Card Cavern frequently offer sealed products at competitive prices, sometimes below MSRP. Shipping costs vary, so factor that into your per-unit price comparison.
Big-Box Wholesale (Costco, Sam's Club) Both carry Pokemon TCG products seasonally, often in value bundles priced below what you'd pay buying individual items at MSRP. Selection is limited and unpredictable, but when they stock TCG products, the pricing is hard to beat.
When your cost to acquire cards goes up, every card in your collection represents a larger investment. That changes the math on grading decisions.
Consider a booster box that costs $143.99 at MSRP vs. $172.79 at GameStop (20% markup). The chase cards inside are the same, but your cost basis is $29 higher. Every card you pull needs to return more value to justify the purchase, and professional grading is one of the primary tools for maximizing card value.
A raw Iono SAR from Paldea Evolved might sell for $80. The same card in a PSA 10 slab sells for $250+. That $170 value increase is the same whether you paid MSRP or above-MSRP for the pack it came from. But when your cost basis is higher, the incentive to extract maximum value from your best pulls is stronger.
This is where pre-screening becomes critical. At $28 per card for PSA grading, you can't afford to submit cards that won't grade well. Higher acquisition costs and higher grading costs compound each other, making every submission decision more consequential.
Use CardGrade's AI pre-grading to evaluate your best pulls before committing to a grading submission. The free centering tool takes 10 seconds per card and eliminates cards that won't pass PSA's 55/45 Gem Mint centering threshold. For a more comprehensive pre-submission guide, see our common grading mistakes article.
GameStop's pricing shift is part of a broader trend. Retailers are discovering they can charge above MSRP for in-demand TCG products, and as long as collectors pay the inflated prices, the practice will continue.
Here's how to adapt:
Track pricing across multiple retailers. Before buying any TCG product, check prices at Pokemon Center, Walmart, Target, TCGPlayer, and your local card shop. GameStop is now often the most expensive option for the same sealed product. Spend five minutes comparing prices before spending $100+ on a product.
Pre-order strategically. Products priced above MSRP at GameStop may be available at MSRP through pre-orders at other retailers. Pokemon Center, Target, and many LCS offer pre-orders for upcoming releases. Lock in MSRP pricing before scalper-friendly pricing kicks in.
Buy singles instead of sealed product. If you're chasing specific cards rather than opening packs for the experience, buying graded or raw singles from the secondary market is almost always cheaper than opening sealed product. A PSA 10 Charizard ex is a known quantity at a known price. A booster box is a gamble.
Focus grading on high-value pulls. When acquisition costs rise, concentrate your grading budget on the cards most likely to earn PSA 10 or CGC 10 and generate meaningful resale premiums. Don't waste grading fees on mid-tier pulls that barely break even at PSA 9. Pre-screen with CardGrade and submit only your best.
Consider alternative TCG formats. Magic: The Gathering, One Piece TCG, and other games have robust collector markets and may offer better value at current pricing levels. Diversifying across TCGs reduces your exposure to any single game's retail pricing fluctuations.
GameStop's above-MSRP pricing for Pokemon TCG products reflects a market where demand consistently outpaces supply for popular releases. As long as Prismatic Evolutions boxes sell at $99.99, GameStop has no incentive to price them at $89.99.
For collectors, the response should be economic: buy where prices are lowest, focus grading dollars on the highest-ROI cards, and treat every acquisition as an investment decision rather than an impulse purchase.
The combination of rising retail costs and rising grading costs means the margin between profit and loss on card collecting is narrower than it's been in years. The collectors who do the math, pre-screen their cards, and optimize their sourcing will continue to do well. The ones who buy above MSRP and submit everything to PSA without screening will find their hobby increasingly expensive and decreasingly profitable.
For more on optimizing your grading submissions, see our guide on whether card grading is worth it.
Pre-screen your cards before submitting to PSA, BGS, or CGC. Start free 3-day trial.
Start free trialAlso available as a Chrome Extension
Grade cards while you browse
Install our free Chrome Extension — right-click any card on eBay, COMC, or TCGPlayer for instant grades.
Founder, CardGrade
Jamie Budesky is the founder of CardGrade and the engineer behind its AI vision grading pipeline. An Army veteran and IT specialist (DoD, since 2017), he writes about card grading, AI/ML grading technology, and collecting strategy — grounded in CardGrade's own grading data.
PSA paused its Value tiers, TAG closed its core submission tiers, and CGC turnaround stretched past 120 working days. Inside the May 2026 card grading backlog — and how to pre-screen with AI before you wait months in line.
PSA is pausing Value Bulk, Value, Value Plus, and Value Max tiers on June 2, 2026, due to a backlog approaching 10 million cards. With the cheapest open tier now $79.99 per card, here is how to decide which cards are worth submitting — and how to pre-screen before you pay.
The card grading industry reached $187M-$312M in 2025 with 12.5 million cards submitted. Full breakdown of market size, company share, pricing, turnaround times, and what it means for collectors.